I've written before about my experiments in using Skype and other IM clients with SUSE Linux and VMware Server (#1, #2, #3, #4).
To date, my summary was:
- Skype - runs OK for voice on SUSE Linux, but not for video. Skype works with audio and video running in a Windows session on VMware Server, but doesn't even work for audio in a SUSE Linux session on VMware Server;
- Yahoo! Messenger 8 - works for audio and video running in a Windows session on VMware Server. No Linux version available yet (but hopefully in future!);
- OpenWengo - available for RedHat, but not for SUSE Linux (and RedHat RPM doesn't work under SUSE Linux).
Now, it happens that my Nokia E61 phone supports VOIP and SIP, so I was to see how well it works. I found instructions for setting it up the Nokia E61 to use the Gizmo service for VOIP, and they worked! That said, the quality of the sound, when I tested ringing my home (UK) phone number, was diabolical, so it really isn't viable as way to use my phone for VOIP calls (I tend to do quite a few of these for overseas teleconference numbers).
In spite of the failure, it made me aware of the Gizmo IM and VOIP client, and I was very interested that it has clients for Windows, Mac, and Linux. That's the kind of cross-platform support I'm particularly interested in.
First I tried Gizmo running in a SUSE Linux 10.1 session under VMware Server. With Skype, when I tried this and phoned it's "echo" service, the sound of the answering voice was stretched out enormously, like a bad special effect. At that point I just gave up. With Gizmo, the sound of the answering voice was fine, I was very impressed. However, I couldn't hear my own voice coming back from the Gizmo "echo" service.
Well, while I haven't confirmed this, it seems that the audio support in Linux guest sessions on VMware Server is one-way. You can listen to audio out, but you can't get audio in. So even if Skype has worked in the SUSE Linux session, it wouldn't have helped me.
Now that I know that I have to do voice IM on my host OS directly (or otherwise in a Windows session), I decided to re-evaluate Skype under SUSE Linux and compare it to Gizmo (which is currently still in beta, though). Short answer is that Skype wins, at least for my setup. I have seen some people report that Gizmo gives them better quality than Skype, and perhaps it depends where in the world you are. For me, the quality of Gizmo calls is OK, but audibly less clear than Skype. Worse, I haven't managed to get a Gizmo call to last more than 30 minutes, which means I can't get it to last for a full 1 or 2 hour teleconference. So, for the moment, I'm back to Skype (at least for teleconferences where I'm able to type in the pass code from Skype. This is a problem with some versions of Skype; I'm still testing a suggestion that muting your sound before dialling the code is the quick fix). However, Gizmo still looks interesting, I'll be watching how it progresses in future releases.
Recent Comments